Rethink urged over High Speed 2 appraisal

Costs on High Speed 2 “do not appear to be under control” and the project’s business case is in urgent need of a new appraisal, says the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee in a new report.

To read more of this and every other news story on this site, please log in with your Construction Law membership account details. If you don't have an account, you can get free access to the news on this site and receive a free newsletter on Fridays by creating a Newsletter account. See the panel to the right.

Subscribers to the printed magazine get access to the entire Construction law website.

Call to reduce focus on capital cost in measuring project success

Government over relies on capital cost to determine project success and should instead recognise the importance of whole life economic, social and environmental value, a report by the Institution of Civil Engineers argues.

To read more of this and every other news story on this site, please log in with your Construction Law membership account details. If you don't have an account, you can get free access to the news on this site and receive a free newsletter on Fridays by creating a Newsletter account. See the panel to the right.

Subscribers to the printed magazine get access to the entire Construction law website.

Two firms handed large fines after ‘avoidable’ fall from height

A construction contractor and a cladding specialist have been fined a combined total of over £300,000 for safety breaches after a fall from height left a worker with life changing injuries.

To read more of this and every other news story on this site, please log in with your Construction Law membership account details. If you don't have an account, you can get free access to the news on this site and receive a free newsletter on Fridays by creating a Newsletter account. See the panel to the right.

Subscribers to the printed magazine get access to the entire Construction law website.

Construction firms agree £1.9m blacklisting payout

Seven major construction companies have agreed to pay £1.9m in compensation to 53 blacklisted workers following a case brought by trade union Unite.

To read more of this and every other news story on this site, please log in with your Construction Law membership account details. If you don't have an account, you can get free access to the news on this site and receive a free newsletter on Fridays by creating a Newsletter account. See the panel to the right.

Subscribers to the printed magazine get access to the entire Construction law website.

Fit out directors disqualified for cartel activity

Three former directors of office fit out companies have been disqualified for their involvement in illegal cartel behaviour as the Competition & Markets Authority (CMA) continues its crack down on the construction sector.

To read more of this and every other news story on this site, please log in with your Construction Law membership account details. If you don't have an account, you can get free access to the news on this site and receive a free newsletter on Fridays by creating a Newsletter account. See the panel to the right.

Subscribers to the printed magazine get access to the entire Construction law website.

Adjudication undermines struggle against adversarial culture

None of the changes in construction practice seen over the past two decades have tackled the underlying causes of the industry’s adversarial culture, writes independent commercial mediator Amanda Bucklow, Guest Editor of the latest edition of Construction Law - the May issue – Vol 30, No 4, which lands on subscribers’ desks this week.

To read more of this and every other news story on this site, please log in with your Construction Law membership account details. If you don't have an account, you can get free access to the news on this site and receive a free newsletter on Fridays by creating a Newsletter account. See the panel to the right.

Subscribers to the printed magazine get access to the entire Construction law website.

Poor contract interfaces hurt Crossrail programme

Crossrail’s contracting approach and a high number of interfaces to manage between contractors were important factors contributing to significant delays and cost increases on the scheme, the National Audit Office has said.

To read more of this and every other news story on this site, please log in with your Construction Law membership account details. If you don't have an account, you can get free access to the news on this site and receive a free newsletter on Fridays by creating a Newsletter account. See the panel to the right.

Subscribers to the printed magazine get access to the entire Construction law website.

IPA chief urges transparency in procurement

Greater transparency of communication is required from the private sector during the procurement of major infrastructure contracts according to the Infrastructure & Projects Authority’s interim chief executive officer Matthew Vickerstaff.

To read more of this and every other news story on this site, please log in with your Construction Law membership account details. If you don't have an account, you can get free access to the news on this site and receive a free newsletter on Fridays by creating a Newsletter account. See the panel to the right.

Subscribers to the printed magazine get access to the entire Construction law website.

Construction Law – May 2019

Editor’s comment
Capital solution for fair payments
Editor Nick Barrett suggests that payments reform legislation might have to be accompanied by measures to help the weak balance sheets of major contractors.

News
Our regular procurement and construction law news round up includes details of a rise in fines for health and safety offences following new sentencing guidance; the roll out of a new pre-qualification system for construction; and the disqualification of two directors over a construction products cartel.

Legal terms explained
Philip Parrott of Herbert Smith Freehills LLP explains what is meant by acceleration.

Guest editor
Honouring the observance rather than the breach
Guest editor Amanda Bucklow, a widely respected Independent Commercial Mediator, says none of the changes in construction practice over the past 20 years or so have tackled the underlying causes of the industry’s adversarial culture. Adjudication has been no help as it undermines both the contract and performance.

Legislation state of play table
Our regular round up of legislation affecting construction as it passes through the UK and EC legislative systems comes from Dentons UK and Middle East LLP whose Gurbinder Grewal and Tracey Summerell provide a commentary on the government’s response to the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy Committee’s recent report on small businesses and productivity.

Reports from the courts
Our latest round up of construction cases comes from Andrew Croft and Ben Spannuth of Beale & Company Solicitors LLP, focussing on a dispute involving failure to submit a payment or pay less notice; and a widely publicised domestic client case that highlights the importance of a written agreement, a clear brief, and clear and accurate record-keeping.

Contracts monitor
Who is in charge?
Our contracts monitor Michael Phipps, Principal of Thurston Consultants, turns his attention to the control of the works section of JCT’s Design and Build Contract 2016. Among new requirements is one for the contractor to appoint a Site Manager approved by the Employer; the person in charge is no more.

CL guides
Insolvency
Ross Galbraith of DLA Piper continues our Guides to Construction Law series with a review of UK insolvency processes and measures that can be taken to spot potential problem contractors and protective steps that can be adopted.

Contracts
Price, scope of works and risk
Suriya Edwards of Foot Anstey LLP warns that a recent court decision means risk allocation clauses relating to works that are not ‘in scope’ can be rendered useless. The link between consideration and risk needs to be underpinned by a clear ‘scope of works’.

Insolvency
Mitigating insolvency effects in the supply chain
Gurbinder Grewal and Michael Wright of Dentons UK and Middle East LLP explain the knock on effects of insolvencies and the mitigating steps that can be taken. Early warning signs of looming insolvency can be spotted.

Liquidated damages after contract termination
Chris Philpot of HFW explains the implications of a court decision for liquidated damages claims following termination of a contract. The question of whether a party failing to issue a pay less notice can start a value adjudication without first paying the notified sum is also considered.

Legislation
Safe as houses: fire safety and the legislative regime – Pt II
In the second part of an article on the fire safety regime in England, barristers Chris Bryden and Georgia Whiting of Chambers of Timothy Raggatt QC move on to a critical examination of current legislation and proposals for reform.

Insurance
Insurance claims – forward planning essential
Insurance expert John D Wright of JD Risk Associates argues that forward planning is essential if proper protection is to be gained from insurance cover. Planning for a successful outcome to an insurance claim must start at the proposal stage.

Alternative dispute resolution
Model mediation agreements
The latest in our alternative dispute resolution series, from Gurbinder Grewal and Tracey Summerell of Dentons UK and Middle East LLP reviews the Construction Industry Council’s proposals for a model mediation agreement and procedure as consulted on towards the end of 2018.